Join our mailing list and be the first to know about new products, sneak peeks, exclusive offers, giveaways, and more! Join!

Join the Super Secret Superhero Pin Club!

This 2-in-1 enamel pin consists of two designs attached by a hinge. The bottom design is of the hero's face and the top design is of the hero's mask or helmet. Just flip up the top design to unmask the superhero!

Our inaugural superhero is Tony Stark/Iron Man!

All future pin designs will be a mystery and will not be revealed until you receive them. We currently have a six-month subscription run planned, but will extend the subscription if there is enough customer demand.

Get Started

Are you a YA fiction fan?

Pre-order the limited edition box for Ashley Poston's "Bookish & the Beast" from the Once Upon A Con series!

Pre-order now.

Are you a Charmed fan?

Harness the Power of Three with Charmed: Box of Shadows, our quarterly subscription box for the ultimate Charmed fan.

Subscribe now.

Check out our shop!

In our shop, you will find unique fandom items from past boxes, limited edition book boxes, SDCC exclusives, and more!

Shop now.


FanMail is one of the best fandom-centric subscription boxes you’ll ever come across. No matter what fandoms you’re a part of, FanMail truly has something for everyone. (And then some.)



FanMail is the ONLY box that has never disappointed me. When other boxes are full of cheap trinkets and always male audience based, FanMail is there. There hasn't been a single thing in any box since they sent out the first one that I haven't liked. Keep up the good work over there! I hope to be a subscriber for my entire life.



I subscribe to several nerdy boxes, and I can honestly say that the FanMail box is consistently my favorite. Some of the others are too concerned with sending out a bunch of branded items and I’m glad you guys have stayed true to real fans!